Understanding Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Causes & Treatment

Introduction

Multiple Substance Use Disorder (MSUD) is a complex condition marked by the use and dependency on more than one substance, such as alcohol, prescription medications, or illicit drugs. This disorder has become a growing global concern, affecting individuals from all walks of life. Historically, substance use disorders were studied in isolation, but research now recognizes that many individuals struggle with the simultaneous use of multiple substances, which complicates both treatment and recovery. This article aims to provide a thorough overview of MSUD, including its risk factors, symptoms, diagnostic methods, treatment options, and self-care strategies. By gaining a deeper understanding of this condition, patients and their loved ones can take the first step toward effective management and recovery.

What is Multiple Substance Use Disorder?

Multiple Substance Use Disorder is defined as the concurrent use of two or more substances, resulting in significant health, social, and psychological challenges. This article delves into its risk factors, symptoms, diagnostic tools, treatment approaches, and self-care strategies to support effective management of the disorder.

Description of Multiple Substance Use Disorder

Multiple Substance Use Disorder (MSUD), also referred to as polysubstance use disorder, involves the simultaneous or sequential misuse of multiple substances, such as alcohol, opioids, stimulants, or sedatives. Often, individuals use one substance to enhance or counteract the effects of another, creating a dangerous cycle of dependency. Over time, this behavior can lead to severe physical and mental health complications, strained relationships, and difficulties maintaining employment or fulfilling daily responsibilities.

The progression of MSUD varies from person to person. For some, it begins with recreational substance use that escalates into habitual use and eventually addiction. Others may develop MSUD while attempting to self-medicate for chronic pain, anxiety, or other underlying conditions. Without timely intervention, the disorder can result in life-threatening complications, including overdose and organ damage.

Statistics highlight the prevalence of MSUD. According to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), nearly 9 million adults in the United States reported using multiple substances in the past year. Additionally, individuals with MSUD are at a heightened risk of co-occurring mental health disorders, such as depression or anxiety, which further complicate their condition. Early recognition and treatment are essential for improving outcomes and supporting long-term recovery.

Risk Factors for Developing Multiple Substance Use Disorder

Lifestyle Risk Factors

Several lifestyle factors contribute to the risk of developing MSUD. Peer pressure and social environments that normalize or encourage substance use play a significant role, particularly among adolescents and young adults. High levels of stress—whether from work, finances, or personal relationships—may also drive individuals to use substances as a coping mechanism. Additionally, easy access to substances through friends, family, or the community increases the likelihood of misuse. Recreational substance use, especially in social settings, can quickly escalate into habitual use, raising the risk of MSUD.

Medical Risk Factors

Medical conditions and health challenges are also significant contributors to MSUD. Chronic pain often leads to the use of prescription opioids, which may be combined with substances like alcohol or sedatives. Mental health disorders, such as depression, anxiety, or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), are strongly linked to substance use as individuals attempt to self-medicate. Major life changes, such as recovering from surgery or managing a serious illness, may involve prescribed medications with dependency risks, particularly when combined with other substances.

Genetic and Age-Related Risk Factors

Genetics and age are critical factors in the development of MSUD. Research indicates that individuals with a family history of substance use disorders are more likely to develop similar conditions due to inherited genetic predispositions. Adolescents and young adults are especially vulnerable to experimenting with substances, which can lead to long-term misuse. Older adults may develop MSUD due to the misuse of prescription medications combined with alcohol or other substances, often as a result of chronic pain or feelings of loneliness. Recognizing these risk factors allows individuals and healthcare providers to identify at-risk populations and implement preventive measures.

Clinical Manifestations of Multiple Substance Use Disorder

Craving

Craving, or an intense desire to use substances, is a hallmark symptom of MSUD, affecting approximately 80–90% of individuals with the disorder. Cravings are often most pronounced during the early stages of the disorder or during periods of abstinence when withdrawal symptoms occur. They arise from changes in the brain’s reward system, particularly in the prefrontal cortex and limbic system, which associate substance use with pleasure and relief. Environmental cues, stress, or memories of past substance use can trigger cravings, making them a persistent challenge during recovery.

Tolerance

Tolerance, reported in 70–85% of MSUD patients, refers to the need for increasing amounts of a substance to achieve the same effect. This occurs as the body adapts to the substance, reducing its sensitivity. For example, someone who initially needed one drink to feel relaxed may eventually require several drinks to achieve the same effect. This escalation often leads to higher consumption, increasing the risk of physical and psychological harm.

Withdrawal Symptoms

Withdrawal symptoms affect 60–75% of individuals with MSUD, particularly during periods of reduced or ceased substance use. These symptoms occur because the body becomes dependent on the substance to function normally. Common withdrawal symptoms include nausea, sweating, tremors, anxiety, and, in severe cases, seizures or hallucinations. The severity of withdrawal depends on the substances involved and the duration of use. For instance, withdrawal from alcohol or opioids can be life-threatening without medical supervision, underscoring the importance of professional care during detoxification.

Loss of Control

Loss of control, reported in 65–80% of MSUD cases, is a defining characteristic of the disorder. It refers to the inability to limit substance use despite intentions to do so. This stems from changes in the brain’s decision-making and impulse-control centers, making it difficult to resist the urge to use substances. Over time, this leads to compulsive behaviors, where substance use becomes the central focus of life, often at the expense of responsibilities and relationships.

Neglecting Responsibilities

Neglecting responsibilities, such as work, school, or family obligations, occurs in 50–70% of MSUD patients. This often results from the time and energy consumed by substance use and its effects. For example, individuals may miss work due to hangovers or prioritize spending money on substances over paying bills. Over time, this neglect can lead to significant personal and professional consequences, exacerbating struggles with MSUD.

Continued Use Despite Problems

Continued use despite problems is observed in 75–85% of MSUD cases. This behavior reflects the compulsive nature of the disorder, where individuals persist in substance use despite being aware of its negative consequences. For instance, someone may continue drinking despite worsening liver conditions or damaged relationships. This symptom highlights the chronic and relapsing nature of MSUD, where the drive to use substances often overrides rational decision-making.

Social or Interpersonal Issues

Social or interpersonal issues affect 60–80% of MSUD patients. These include conflicts with family members, strained friendships, or isolation from social networks. Substance use often alters behavior, leading to arguments, trust issues, or neglect of loved ones. Additionally, individuals may withdraw from social activities to hide their substance use or avoid judgment, further isolating themselves and worsening feelings of loneliness and depression.

Risky Behavior

Risky behavior, such as driving under the influence or engaging in unsafe sexual practices, occurs in 40–60% of individuals with MSUD. These behaviors often result from impaired judgment and lowered inhibitions caused by substance use. Risky behavior not only endangers the individual but also poses risks to others, highlighting the broader societal impact of MSUD. Addressing these behaviors is a critical component of treatment and recovery.

Physical Health Problems

Physical health problems are present in 50–70% of MSUD patients and vary depending on the substances used. Common issues include liver damage (from alcohol), respiratory problems (from smoking), and cardiovascular issues (from stimulants). Chronic substance use weakens the immune system, increasing susceptibility to infections and illnesses. These health problems often prompt individuals to seek help but can also complicate treatment and recovery efforts.

Psychological Issues

Psychological issues, such as anxiety, depression, or paranoia, affect 60–80% of individuals with MSUD. These issues may precede substance use or develop as a consequence of it. For example, untreated depression may lead someone to use substances for relief, only to find that their use worsens mental health over time. Addressing these psychological issues is essential for effective treatment, as they often perpetuate the cycle of substance use and relapse.

Health Conditions with Similar Symptoms to Multiple Substance Use Disorder

Alcohol Use Disorder

Definition: Alcohol use disorder (AUD) is a condition characterized by an inability to regulate alcohol consumption despite negative consequences. It can range from mild to severe and often includes cravings, withdrawal symptoms, and continued drinking even when it harms health, relationships, or responsibilities.

How to know if you might have Alcohol Use Disorder vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both AUD and multiple substance use disorder involve cravings, withdrawal symptoms, and difficulty controlling substance use. However, AUD is specific to alcohol, while multiple substance use disorder involves two or more substances. Unique symptoms of AUD include blackouts (memory loss during drinking), liver damage, and alcohol-specific withdrawal symptoms such as tremors, seizures, or delirium tremens. Diagnostic tools like liver function tests (elevated liver enzymes) and blood alcohol concentration can help distinguish AUD. If these tests indicate chronic alcohol use without evidence of other substances, AUD may be the primary diagnosis.

Depression

Definition: Depression is a mood disorder marked by persistent sadness, hopelessness, and a lack of interest in activities. It can also affect physical health, leading to changes in sleep, appetite, and energy levels.

How to know if you might have Depression vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Depression and multiple substance use disorder share symptoms such as fatigue, difficulty concentrating, and sleep disturbances. However, depression does not involve the cravings or withdrawal symptoms typical of substance use disorders. A hallmark of depression is a pervasive low mood or loss of interest in nearly all activities, which is not necessarily present in substance use disorders. Tools like the PHQ-9 questionnaire can help assess depression. If symptoms persist without substance use or withdrawal, depression may be the primary condition.

Anxiety Disorders

Definition: Anxiety disorders are mental health conditions characterized by excessive fear, worry, or nervousness. They can interfere with daily life and may include physical symptoms such as a racing heart, sweating, or gastrointestinal discomfort.

How to know if you might have Anxiety Disorders vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both conditions can cause restlessness, difficulty concentrating, and sleep disturbances. However, anxiety disorders are defined by persistent worry or fear unrelated to substance use. In contrast, these symptoms in multiple substance use disorder are often tied to substance effects or withdrawal. Diagnostic tools like the GAD-7 questionnaire can help identify anxiety disorders. If anxiety symptoms occur independently of substance use, an anxiety disorder may be the underlying issue.

Bipolar Disorder

Definition: Bipolar disorder is a mental health condition characterized by extreme mood swings, including manic episodes (high energy and euphoria) and depressive episodes (low mood and energy).

How to know if you might have Bipolar Disorder vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both conditions can involve mood changes, impulsivity, and risky behaviors. However, bipolar disorder’s mood swings are not caused by substance use and often follow a cyclical pattern. Unique to bipolar disorder are manic episodes, which may include grandiosity, decreased need for sleep, and rapid speech. Tools like the Mood Disorder Questionnaire (MDQ) can help assess bipolar disorder. If mood symptoms persist outside of substance use or withdrawal, bipolar disorder may be the primary diagnosis.

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

Definition: PTSD is a mental health condition that develops after experiencing or witnessing a traumatic event. It is characterized by flashbacks, nightmares, and severe anxiety related to the trauma.

How to know if you might have PTSD vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both PTSD and multiple substance use disorder can involve anxiety, irritability, and sleep disturbances. However, PTSD is distinguished by trauma-specific symptoms such as flashbacks, avoidance of trauma reminders, and hypervigilance, which are not typical of substance use disorders. Tools like the PTSD Checklist (PCL-5) can help assess symptoms. If these symptoms are linked to a traumatic event and occur independently of substance use, PTSD may be the primary condition.

Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)

Definition: ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity. It often begins in childhood but can persist into adulthood.

How to know if you might have ADHD vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both conditions can involve impulsivity and difficulty concentrating. However, ADHD symptoms are typically lifelong and not caused by substance use. Unique to ADHD are challenges with organization, time management, and sustained attention, which are not features of substance use disorders. Tools like the Adult ADHD Self-Report Scale (ASRS) can help evaluate symptoms. If these symptoms have been present since childhood and are not linked to substance use, ADHD may be the primary diagnosis.

Personality Disorders

Definition: Personality disorders are mental health conditions characterized by enduring patterns of behavior, cognition, and emotion that deviate from cultural norms and cause significant distress or impairment.

How to know if you might have Personality Disorders vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both conditions can involve impulsivity, mood instability, and interpersonal difficulties. However, personality disorders are long-standing and not caused by substance use. Unique features include ingrained patterns of behavior and thought that persist across various situations. Structured interviews or tools like the Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire (PDQ) can help assess these conditions. If these patterns are evident across the lifespan and independent of substance use, a personality disorder may be the primary diagnosis.

Psychotic Disorders

Definition: Psychotic disorders, such as schizophrenia, involve a disconnection from reality. Symptoms may include hallucinations, delusions, and disorganized thinking.

How to know if you might have Psychotic Disorders vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both conditions can involve hallucinations or delusions. However, psychotic symptoms in substance use disorders are typically tied to intoxication or withdrawal and resolve with abstinence. In contrast, psychotic disorders involve persistent symptoms unrelated to substance use. Tools like the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS) can help assess psychotic symptoms. If these symptoms persist independently of substance use, a psychotic disorder may be the primary diagnosis.

Medical Conditions Related to Substance Use

Definition: These are physical health conditions that arise as a direct result of substance use, such as liver disease, heart problems, or neurological damage.

How to know if you might have Medical Conditions Related to Substance Use vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both can involve physical symptoms like fatigue, weight loss, or changes in appearance. However, medical conditions related to substance use are specific to the affected organ system and may not involve cravings or withdrawal symptoms. Diagnostic tests like imaging studies, blood tests, or organ function tests can help identify these conditions. If physical symptoms are linked to organ damage rather than substance use behaviors, a medical condition may be the primary diagnosis.

Behavioral Addictions

Definition: Behavioral addictions are compulsive behaviors that activate the brain’s reward system, similar to substance use. Examples include gambling, gaming, or shopping addictions.

How to know if you might have Behavioral Addictions vs. Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Both conditions involve compulsive behaviors and difficulty stopping despite negative consequences. However, behavioral addictions do not involve the physical withdrawal symptoms seen in substance use disorders. Tools like the South Oaks Gambling Screen (SOGS) or similar questionnaires can help assess behavioral addictions. If compulsive behaviors occur without substance use or withdrawal, a behavioral addiction may be the primary condition.

Treatment Options

Medications

Buprenorphine: A partial opioid agonist used to treat opioid use disorder, buprenorphine reduces cravings and withdrawal symptoms without causing intense euphoria. It is particularly effective for individuals with multiple substance use disorders involving opioids.

Methadone: A long-acting opioid agonist, methadone alleviates withdrawal symptoms and blocks the euphoric effects of other opioids. It is often recommended for severe opioid dependence or cases unresponsive to other treatments.

Naltrexone: An opioid antagonist, naltrexone blocks the effects of opioids and alcohol, reducing cravings and preventing relapse. It is typically used after detoxification to maintain abstinence in individuals with opioid or alcohol use disorders.

Acamprosate: Acamprosate helps maintain alcohol abstinence by modulating brain activity and reducing cravings. It is prescribed for individuals committed to long-term recovery after stopping alcohol use.

Disulfiram: Disulfiram discourages alcohol consumption by causing unpleasant reactions when alcohol is ingested. It is suitable for highly motivated individuals who can adhere to the treatment plan.

Topiramate: An anticonvulsant, topiramate shows promise in reducing cravings for alcohol and other substances. It is often used off-label for substance use disorders.

Gabapentin: Commonly used for nerve pain and seizures, gabapentin also reduces alcohol cravings and withdrawal symptoms. It is frequently prescribed off-label for alcohol use disorder.

Lofexidine: A non-opioid medication, lofexidine reduces withdrawal symptoms during opioid detoxification, managing anxiety and agitation.

Varenicline: Primarily used to help individuals quit smoking, varenicline reduces cravings and withdrawal symptoms. It is occasionally used off-label for other substance use disorders.

Clonidine: Clonidine helps manage withdrawal symptoms by calming the sympathetic nervous system. It is often used during opioid or alcohol detoxification.

Procedures

While medications play a central role in treating multiple substance use disorder, behavioral therapies, counseling, and rehabilitation programs are essential for a comprehensive approach. These interventions are tailored to the individual and often include a combination of one-on-one therapy, group therapy, and family counseling to address the psychological and social aspects of addiction.

Improving Multiple Substance Use Disorder with Lifestyle Changes and Medical Help

In addition to professional substance abuse treatment, incorporating lifestyle changes and home-based strategies can significantly enhance recovery from multiple substance use disorder or polysubstance use disorder. Below are some practical and effective approaches:

1. Exercise: Engaging in regular physical activity can elevate mood, alleviate stress, and improve overall well-being—key components of a successful recovery journey.
2. Meditation: Practicing mindfulness and meditation can help manage cravings, reduce anxiety, and foster emotional resilience.
3. Support Groups: Participating in groups like Alcoholics Anonymous or Narcotics Anonymous provides a sense of community, accountability, and shared understanding.
4. Healthy Diet: A well-balanced diet supports both physical and mental recovery, helping to stabilize mood and energy levels while addressing substance use disorder symptoms.
5. Journaling: Writing down thoughts and emotions can aid in processing feelings, tracking progress, and identifying potential triggers for substance use.
6. Mindfulness: Practicing mindfulness techniques helps reduce stress and improve coping skills, which are essential for navigating the challenges of addiction recovery.
7. Adequate Sleep: Prioritizing quality sleep is vital for restoring mental and physical health, counteracting the toll of chronic substance use disorder.
8. Stress Management: Techniques such as yoga, deep breathing exercises, or progressive muscle relaxation can help reduce stress and minimize triggers for relapse.
9. Social Support: Building a strong network of supportive friends and family members can provide emotional stability and reinforce recovery efforts.

If you or someone you care about is struggling with multiple substance use disorder, seeking professional medical help is essential. Telemedicine offers a convenient and accessible way to connect with healthcare providers, develop personalized treatment plans, and receive ongoing support from the comfort of home. This approach is particularly effective for addressing co-occurring mental health and addiction challenges.

Living with Multiple Substance Use Disorder: Tips for a Better Quality of Life

Living with multiple substance use disorder or polysubstance use disorder can be challenging, but recovery is achievable with the right tools and support. Here are some practical tips to help improve your quality of life:

1. Stay committed to your treatment plan and attend all scheduled appointments with your healthcare provider to ensure consistent progress.
2. Build a reliable support network that includes friends, family, and professionals experienced in addiction counseling services.
3. Practice self-care by prioritizing restorative sleep, maintaining a nutritious diet, and incorporating regular physical activity into your daily routine.
4. Identify and actively avoid triggers, such as certain environments or social situations, that could increase the risk of relapse.
5. Set achievable goals and celebrate small victories to maintain motivation and a positive outlook throughout your recovery journey.
6. Utilize telemedicine for regular check-ins with your healthcare team, addressing concerns promptly and ensuring continuity in your substance dependence treatment.

Recovery is a gradual process, and setbacks are a natural part of the journey. Stay focused on your long-term goals, seek help when needed, and remain committed to making steady progress. With the right support system and strategies, it is possible to overcome the challenges of polysubstance use and mental health disorders.

Conclusion

Multiple substance use disorder is a complex condition that requires a comprehensive and individualized treatment approach. Early diagnosis and intervention can greatly improve outcomes, empowering individuals to regain control of their lives and achieve lasting recovery. Addressing co-occurring mental health and addiction issues is equally critical for long-term success.

Our telemedicine practice is dedicated to providing compassionate, personalized care for individuals facing multiple substance use disorder. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and take the first step toward a healthier, more fulfilling life. Whether you are seeking primary care addiction treatment or exploring options for dual diagnosis treatment, we are here to support you every step of the way.

James Kingsley

Learn More